If there is one thing that I have learned as a parent, it is that parenting is an extremely personal endeavor.
I talked to my aunt this morning, who was telling me about a friend whose daughter just had a baby. Unfortunately, the daughter's birth did not go as she had "planned." First, she had to have a c-section (disappointment #1). Then, she was exhausted after the birth and could not keep her milk supply up and consequently could not breastfeed as she had planned (disappointment #2). Now, all of the "books" say that breastfeeding is best, and I do not dispute that in the least. But what this poor lady is going through is so emotionally draining because all the "books" say that she should try harder, keep breastfeeding, try, try, try, when all she wants is to get some sleep and keep her baby healthy! I completely identify with her because I, too, wasn't able to keep up my milk supply after I went back to work, and it was miserable for me trying to do everything possible to make more milk. Finally, I decided the stress was too much and we went to bottles and formula. I grieved for a long time over it, because I enjoyed it and I felt like I was doing something really good for my baby. But simply giving nutrition is more important than HOW the baby gets it. I fully endorse breastfeeding for anyone who can, and endorse trying for a while to get it to work right before switching to a bottle, but in the end, the important thing is to get the baby nourished.
My point is, society tells us, as parents, that we must follow the orders of some book, or some doctor, and if we don't, we are bad parents. Even our friends (myself included!) are guilty of passing judgement on other parents in regards to their decisions. This is very sad.
What I have learned is to listen to my baby and my own body and my own intuition. Now, for the disclaimer: this blog is not intended to belittle any particular parenting style or make anyone feel bad for the choices they have made as a parent. As I said before, it is so, so personal how we care for our children! And one more thing: I'm not condoning behaviors that harm the children. I'm simply saying that we, as parents, should not be made to feel bad about decisions regarding our parenting.
When we took Zander to his well-baby checkup at either 6 or 9 months, the provider was clearly unnerved by the fact that he still took his bottle and fell asleep and was then placed in the crib. She said that we should have been putting him down awake a long time ago, and it was time to do that now. I understand the physical reason for this--he needs to have his teeth brushed and the milk and other "cavity causers" washed out before he sleeps. But what about the emotional part? For a long time, we followed this care provider's advice, but it was excruciating, listening to him cry for sometimes 1 hour while we just sat downstairs trying to ignore it. Neither of us was comfortable with it. But "the book" and "the doctor" both said that it was best. Recently, we came to a compromise. We give him dinner and his bottle, then bath, brush teeth, read stories and then it's bedtime. I usually rock him until he falls asleep or is very close, before putting him in the crib. This is perfect for all of us. Zander was telling me that he didn't like sitting in his crib alone to fall asleep; my job as his mom is to listen to that. My body was telling me I didn't like hearing him fuss to go to sleep; my job is to also listen to myself. Besides, what is more wonderful that having your sleeping child relax into your body, snuggling his head down close to your heart, tucking his hands in between your body and his, and falling asleep quickly? It literally takes him about 5 minutes to fall asleep when we do it this way.
Am I worried that he might get too dependent on this? Yes, in some ways, but I also think that when he gets a little older, and we move him to a big boy bed, he will transition just fine, with our love and support. I don't know any ten-year-olds who need to be rocked to sleep and I bet there are plenty of other parents who rock their babies and toddlers to sleep!
Am I concerned that I can't leave him with a babysitter because he needs his mom to go to sleep? Yes, and there are nights that I let him fuss a little to get used to the fact that he's alone sometimes. And there are nights that I simply don't have the energy to rock him now that he's such a big boy! But I think the benefits of this arrangement far outweight these supposed "inconveniences." It just feels right for our family.
Another example is the bottle-to-cup transition. We were told that Zander needed to be off the bottle by a year old. We started transitioning to a cup around 9 months, and he wasn't really interested but since the doctor said "no bottle by one year," we kept pushing it. Again, it was torture trying to force him to drink from a cup that he just didn't want. I tried sippy cups with valves, sippy cups with no valves, cups with no lid....he just was not interested. So about the same time I came to the conclusion about the sleeping arrangement, I realized that Zander was telling me that he just wasn't ready to give up the bottle. He especially likes it at night, after dinner, when he can snuggle with mom or dad for a few minutes while he takes his bottle. He drinks from a cup well now, and gets his cup at every meal full of milk, and the daycare still gives him bottles, but he is just not ready to give it up entirely. And I respect that.
Now, some may disagree with me and that's fine! Another arrangement might work better for another family, and as I said before, that's a personal choice and no one should be made to feel bad about that. But also, I shouldn't be made to feel like I made a wrong decision, either. It's what works best for us, period. Zander is happy, healthy, well-adjusted, and strongly attached to both of his parents and multiple caregivers, and to me, that's the most important part.
Whew! It feels good to get that off my mind. It's been bothering me for some time. I think it's really important to just feel good about the decisions we make for our children and know that we are doing what's best (again, not decisions that harm the child).
Now, for some pictures: We never get tired of the bathtime photos, particularly the "shampoo mohawk" pictures! So, for your viewing pleasure....
Doesn't he look like he's trying out for American Idol in this picture? :)