I had an ugly exchange with a complete stranger on Facebook yesterday. I've tried to make myself forget about it, since it was a complete stranger and it shouldn't bother me, but it has just been eating away at me for the past two days, and I felt compelled to write about it. Perhaps writing about it will be cathartic enough to help me get to sleep at this late hour.
An old classmate posted his status as wishing his daughter a happy 6-month birthday. The thread went along happily until someone brought up the dreaded H1N1 vaccine, in the context that the young girl was "finally old enough" to receive it. My classmate responded by saying that he tries not to vaccinate his child or children because of the risk of autism due to the mercury in vaccines.
Wha.....?
Another friend of his, "Tim," posted a comment to the effect of, vaccines are the root of the autism problem, the only way to prevent autism is to stop vaccinating children, and he cited a website as a starting point for anyone interested in researching his point. It seemed very left-field (or should I say right-field?) to me, so I checked it out. The site had zero scientific basis, and was basically anecdotal evidence linking autism to vaccines. It puzzled me to see a comparison chart showing the effects of mercury poisoning being the same symptoms of autism. It made me wonder, if the symptoms of both are the same, how would you know conclusively that your child had autism, and not mercury poisoning?
But I digress.
I, being the loudmouth that I am, decided to post the "other" side of the story. I completed my bachelor's senior thesis on therapy for autism, which required extensive research into the subject. I also have worked in a school where we have four plus classrooms of autistic children, ranging in age from 3 to 10. In addition, I was the lead teacher for a classroom where there were several borderline-PDD children (Pervasive Developmental Disorder). So, I felt I had some background into the disorder and could provide insight into the other side. The gist of my response was that there is no scientific evidence that conclusively links autism to vaccines. Furthermore, autism has been and remains a mystery disease. There are many theories as to its origins, and some believe it may have a genetic link or an environmental link, but there is no scientific evidence linking it to vaccines. I also stated that the risk of developing autism is extremely small compared to the risk of developing sicknesses from the very diseases we are attempting to vaccinate against. I felt that I was respectful, informative, and kind.
After I had posted my response, the friend, "Tim," posted an extremely inflammatory response likening me to an ignorant "sheep" who has done no research into the topic, and I must have voted for Obama also, and believe that global warming is a man-made phenomena. (by the way, I'm intelligent enough to realize that women contributed to global warming as much as men) He advised me to wake UP and stop quoting the status quo and believing everything "pharma" puts out. He also advised my classmate to "stop being nice to the liberals" because the "Republic of the United States of America" was headed to ruins but "that's just fine, right?"
Again I say, "Wha....?"
My response was simply, "How sad. I thought this was a mature discussion between adults without name-calling or insults." Then I removed the classmate from my friend list.
Here's where I am having an issue. First, I AM educated about the autism vs. vaccines. Not only as a professional educator, but also as a parent. I would never do anything to intentionally put my child at risk. I use cloth diapers, fed him organic baby food, try to limit the amount of processed food he eats, and balance fresh fruits and vegetables with fatty meats and carbohydrates. As much as possible, I use cleansers and baby cosmetics that are organic at the very least, or free from harmful steroids or chemicals. I wash his hands frequently, and, yes, I do vaccinate him against diseases. I know, *gasp*, right?
Second, there are so many things in our world that hold potential risk for humans, and I feel like this person was being quite hypocritical. For example, "research" has linked cell phone usage to brain cancer but I would bet a lot of money that he still uses one. Disposable diapers are made using chemicals that leech into the child's skin, but I would also be willing to bet that he used or uses them on his children. Birth control has been linked to ovarian cancer, but I wonder what his wife did to prevent pregnancy? Even driving away from your house poses some risk to yourself and others, but people choose to take that risk everyday. There are so many things that could cause harm that the only way he could avoid them all is by going and living in a cave for the rest of his life without having any contact with the outside world. Which is fine and dandy with me. I don't want his disease-infested children interfering with my child.
Sorry, that was uncalled for.
Here's my final thought: while he's busy accusing me of all sorts of mean things, my husband is in a foreign land, risking his life every day so that people like this lunatic can continue to spout off their beliefs and insult people whom they do not know, in the name of "free speech." So he can feel free to put his opinions you-know-where, and if he is able to get off his high horse long enough, thank my husband for his service. He can thank me for MY sacrifice too, while he's at it.
Maybe I'm just too....nice....but I believe that a person's actions should, as much as possible, not negatively affect other people on the planet. His words were hurtful, scathing, and uncalled for.
I don't really care where you stand on the vaccines vs. autism debate. We can still be friends, even if we disagree. I'm mature enough to admit that I'm not going to see eye-to-eye with everyone in the world. I'm also mature enough to have adult debates with you about things I firmly believe in. But again, it will not fracture our friendship or my feelings for you unless you devolve into name-calling and insulting. I just feel bad for other people who have to listen to that kind of one-sided BS and then make a rash decision based on one person's extreme value system. I believe in fair representation of all issues--both sides, all facets.
I think this incident has scared me enough that I won't be engaging in such a debate any time soon. Which is, in my opinion, sad. There. I feel better already. Now off to try to get some sleep. Thank you for reading to the bitter end, if you did. :)
Saturday, October 31, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
How frustrating. Good post...Dont' the best posts come from writing about something that we are passionate about??
ReplyDeleteCamille. I LOVED this blog. And not just b/c I agree with you! LOL Your reply to him was respectful and mature and he responded by being an idiot. Please don't let it bother you any longer! I always hesistate to jump into any kind of discussion like that - although I have and luckily I haven't been ambushed like you were. Please brush it off, sister!
ReplyDeleteI had an interaction like this with an old high school friend. He accused me of being racist because I'm a Christian and then HE unfriended ME. What a jerk. I'm all for people having thier own opinions, but it kinda defeats the purpose when they attack others for having the opposite opinion!!
ReplyDelete